Daniel P. Barron

Harm doesn't apply to the child here?

Saturday, April 20, 2019

DoctorT345: If abortion becomes classified as murder.

Pro-life Christians- There are women in prison in El Salvador for having an abortion and some for having a miscarriage if it's suspected that they had a hand in it (taking plan B). Do you have an endgame that would prevent this from happening here, or is this the future?

Daniel: Why shouldn't that be the future? The women who have abortions are murderers.

BrosephRatzinger: Actually if abortion is legal it cannot be murder, per the definition of murder.

Daniel: Biblical murder; not what the state considers.

BrosephRatzinger: I don't think that abortion fits the Bible's definition of murder either. Modern Christianity's maybe.

Daniel: Check out the link. There's a passage of the Bible describing how the unborn have a right to live just like an adult. That the punishment for killing an unborn baby is death.

BrosephRatzinger: Quite the opposite. If an unborn dies as a result of the fight a fine must be paid. If the woman dies then it's death. Thus an unborn's life is not on par with a person's.

Daniel: Where does it say the fine is regarding death of the baby? I don't see it that way.

ithran_dishon: Numerous translations have that verse explicitly referring to a miscarriage, which would imply a marked difference in severity between abortion/miscarriage and murder.

Daniel: The translation I quoted is a more literal one. And the miscarriage is the result of an attack on the women. And the point is, the baby is considered to be a person with rights. That's why the punishment is "a life for a life."

ithran_dishon: Again, many translations strongly suggest that a "life for a life" refers to ill befalling the mother.


And if men fight, and they hit a pregnant woman, and her children come out, and there is no harm

Harm doesn't apply to the child here? You're saying that if a woman doesn't want an abortion, and someone punches her in the gut causing a miscarriage, harm hasn't been done?

Wiredpyro: Stop self plugging.


Why shouldn't that be the future? The women who have abortions are murderers.

Not all abortions are of a live baby. Procedures to remove a dead baby are classified as abortions too.

2 Responses

  1. [...] I am not in favor of population control and I believe abortion is murder. God, who creates life, also [...]

Leave a Reply

Your words may be altered or altogether purged in accordance with my preference to abstain from publishing statements that may be unnecessarily offensive to other readers. Your criticism is welcome. Your name and website are optional. Some HTML tags are allowed.